May 012015
 

Photo courtesy of Emmy Magazine, May 12 issue, via E! Entertainment Television, LLC.

There was a flood of new, mainstream reviewers talking about Outlander this week (E! has been on it from the start, but they’re the ones who broke the newest pictures on Thursday, the scintillating one above included). The attention is GREAT news for our series—the payoff for not only a quality show but an extraordinary, inhuman volume of PR work. All of the articles and interviews have boggled my thoughts about last week’s episode, though. It’s tough to take in and process the myriad reactions there were to Lallybroch.

That’s another difference between a television review and a storytelling study (I laid out the main differences, as I see them, in last week’s post). If I claimed to be a true reviewer, reading other critiques before writing my own would be like scamming the exam answers over the shoulder of the brainiac in seat next to mine. As it is, I’m studying how this great story is reaching and affecting its audience, as much I’m examining the adaptation on its own merits. As Maurice Sendak said: “There’s so much more to a book than just the reading.” That’s just as true about good television.

You can have your cake and eat it too, if you choose to
The most vehement opinions, both in support of and disparaging of Lallybroch, are coming from those who read the novels. With each passing week, the “that’s now how it was in the book” outcry is escalating on one side, while the “Everything is Awesome!” automatons on the other side are deriding anyone with anything bad to say. Both reactions are natural, even valid within reason. Viewers, regardless of the book familiarity and life experience they bring to the show, are becoming more invested as the stakes and tensions continue to rise. Deviations from expectations become personal, causing any number of minimizing (“Everything is cool when you’re part of a team!”) and maximizing (How dare my favorite line be omitted from the novel, and has anyone noticed that Cait’s too tall and doesn’t have whisky-amber eyes?) defensive patterns. Yes, I went back to my Psych 101 notes to look up those terms.

Recognizing the flagship series for which Basket of Kisses was founded, I think it’s high time to look at how Outlander‘s doing in two psychological categories for which Mad Men set the standard: patient plot weaving and nuanced character development.

There’s also the coping mechanism similarity for both lead characters.

Continue reading »

FacebookGoogle+RedditShare
May 012015
 

Photo Credit:Courtesy of AMC

Photo Credit:Courtesy of AMC

In Mad Men episode 7.10, The Forecast, Joan meets Richard Burghoff, a wealthy older man with a slender build. Their first night together, he wants her to blow off returning to New York and take a trip with him. She says “Richard, that sounds wonderful.” Except the way she says “Richard,” the first time I heard it, it sounded like “Roger.” Go ahead and play the scene if it’s on your DVR or iTunes–the vowel sound slips from “i” to “o”; sort of “Ro…chard”. Is that deliberate? I don’t know. Continue reading »

FacebookGoogle+RedditShare
"Time" in Time & Life

“Time” in Time & Life

Apr 30, 2015

One of the things I work pretty hard at is finding out exactly when each Mad Men episode takes place. In general, there’s a calendar visible somewhere, or somebody mentions a news event…something. I am delighted to discover that the only indicator in episode 7.11, Time & Life, is…Time. The magazine, that is. It’s visible […]

Full Story
Mad Men Haiku!

Mad Men Haiku!

Apr 30, 2015

More formal goodbye Glen comes back for some Betty Mrs. Robinson

Full Story
Matthew Weiner at 92Y--Theme Starts with Story

Matthew Weiner at 92Y–Theme Starts with Story

Apr 29, 2015

On the night of Tuesday, April 28, the Lipp Sisters attended “An Evening with Matthew Weiner” (creator of Mad Men, as if you didn’t know) at the 92nd Street Y in New York. Matt was his usual fascinating self. This time he was interviewed by Richard LaGravenese, a writer interviewing a writer about writing. At […]

Full Story
Joan's future at McCann-Erickson

Joan’s future at McCann-Erickson

Apr 28, 2015

In discussing Mad Men episode 7.11, Time & Life, a number of Basketcases have speculated on Joan’s fate at McCann. Will she be given any accounts? Will she be fired, with her contract bought out? To me it’s pretty obvious what Joan despaired of, when she said to Pete, “he listed off accounts for everyone […]

Full Story
Jennifer Getzinger Exclusive Interview, Part 3--the wrap up!

Jennifer Getzinger Exclusive Interview, Part 3–the wrap up!

Apr 28, 2015

Jennifer Getzinger sat down with us for over an hour. In this segment, we discuss A Little Kiss, Orange is the New Black, Michael Ginzberg’s nipple, the job of script supervisor, and the influence of Darren Aronofsky. Here’s Part One and Part Two. Deborah Lipp: You’re working with amazing ensembles. Now you’ve also done Orange […]

Full Story
Mad Men Recap: Time & Life--What's in a name?

Mad Men Recap: Time & Life–What’s in a name?

Apr 27, 2015

Mad Men episode 7.11, Time & Life, is Jared Harris’s directorial debut, and I can only say, Welcome! This is the best episode of Mad Men since Waterloo. Harris deftly juggled a huge range of moods, subtly and not-so-subtly calling back to earlier episodes, and toying with our expectations throughout. I’m not going to end […]

Full Story
Coffee With Shirley: The Sola Bamis Interview

Coffee With Shirley: The Sola Bamis Interview

Apr 25, 2015

Note to readers: This interview took place via email. I have taken a couple of liberties to make it seem more “chatty.” Sola Bamis is someone the Basket knows and loves for her portrayal of Mad Men‘s Shirley, admin par excellence at SC&P. Shirley and Dawn are the first African-American employees at the agency, providing […]

Full Story